K20 Versus Turbo D17???
The D17 is slowly getting the support it needs, like the KMS manifold which would help if y turboed it. I still think the k20 or frankenstein swap has more potential, but I would love saying "You got beat by a 1.7 liter" if you went the turbo d17 road. And you could crank down the boost and get better mileage and better power to weight ratio than the frankenstein.
The Beez Kneez
iTrader: (15)
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 3,759
Likes: 0
From: Und3Rgr0unD
Rep Power: 315 

holy **** 15000 is a lot of money i think if you go with d17 turbo you will eventully run out of options. there is only so much you can do with a sohc d series there isnt really a big market for this motor.
i would go with the k20a2 full front clip that would be real nice then you would really stand out from the crowd
imp:
15k dddaaammmmmmmmmmnnn that makes me sick
uke:
i would go with the k20a2 full front clip that would be real nice then you would really stand out from the crowd
imp:15k dddaaammmmmmmmmmnnn that makes me sick
uke: Its good to see my thread back up again thanks for all the info again guys.....but what do you guys think is it better to keep the D17 and do internals and turbo or K20 with internal and I did keep inmind about the weight of the K20 would it really make a difference in performance in my civic bad or good, and I am really thinking about the K20, but I don't want the weight to kill me, what do you guys think
i would definitely go with the k20a2, thats the type s motor, and i am positive it will win against a d17 turbo. caranddriver tested the type s in the 0-60 and they got 6.1sec, heres the link
http://www.caranddriver.com/article....&page_number=1
you will also get a 7900 redline.
http://www.caranddriver.com/article....&page_number=1
you will also get a 7900 redline.
i say why not just buy a S2000 and call it a day, either way you would smoke both a Civic with turbo or an Civic with a K20 swap with turbo
My friend has a Vortech supercharger and he gets around 320 HP in his S2000
My friend has a Vortech supercharger and he gets around 320 HP in his S2000 Because some of us are not fortunate enough to afford a s2k, and others may enjoy modding a civic more than buying another car and "calling it a day".
And there is someone on the boards that will own your friend's S2000. Bad.
And there is someone on the boards that will own your friend's S2000. Bad.
Talking about weight issues...the K20A seems to be 90lbs lighter than any B-series engine according to what i've heard from somewhere i forgot...
but can you confirm me the weight of a K20A and a K24 if have that info? i can't seem to find it anywhere...they always talk about the car's weight but not the engine's weight...
another thing you should consider is a turbo D17 wouldn't last as long as a N/A tuned K20A...
i'm not a mechanic and can't go technique on that but simply think of the fact that turbo pushes your car to its limits and will defenately shorten its life...it's simple and logic...(and our engines are not meant to be turbo'd)
if that's your everyday driver, you should also consider gas/mileage...i think turbo drinks like a bitch...
anyways...i would defenately go for the K20A...i don't like turbos anyways...it seems to fukk your car up good...lol...anyways...
but can you confirm me the weight of a K20A and a K24 if have that info? i can't seem to find it anywhere...they always talk about the car's weight but not the engine's weight...
another thing you should consider is a turbo D17 wouldn't last as long as a N/A tuned K20A...
i'm not a mechanic and can't go technique on that but simply think of the fact that turbo pushes your car to its limits and will defenately shorten its life...it's simple and logic...(and our engines are not meant to be turbo'd)
if that's your everyday driver, you should also consider gas/mileage...i think turbo drinks like a bitch...
anyways...i would defenately go for the K20A...i don't like turbos anyways...it seems to fukk your car up good...lol...anyways...
if you keep the boost down for daily driving the gas mileage will be affected much. Maybe skin off like 1 or 2 mpg. Ya the turbo will harm the D17 in the long run even if preperly put together, meaning that maybe after 100k mi+ you will have probs, versus a K20 should be able to go 200k mi no prob. Internals done on either engine will also limit their life span too- remember.
Originally posted by SMURF_KILLER
I was thinking about that, but I have to do other things too.....I need all new suspension, new rims and tires a body kit because I have no front bumper due to drifting. Need to straighten my frame because of that, new exhaust and need to remove all the dents and repaint my whole care. I am one big mess right now
I was thinking about that, but I have to do other things too.....I need all new suspension, new rims and tires a body kit because I have no front bumper due to drifting. Need to straighten my frame because of that, new exhaust and need to remove all the dents and repaint my whole care. I am one big mess right now
How exactly do u drift in your civic????With 15k the best option is to buy a faster car, but if I had to choose I would go with k20, because then if u still need more power u can get a turbo for the k20; rather than buying a turbo for the d17 then finding out u still want more power and having to crack open the engine in a desperate attempt to increase your BOOST!
Last edited by JoeyCrac; Oct 28, 2003 at 11:57 AM.
Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 3,101
Likes: 0
From: Los Angeles, CA
Rep Power: 0 
i say if your going to do other work to the car, such as suspension, exterior, interior work... you'll have about $11.5K to work with if you go the SF Turbo route because it will cost you around $3.5k...
Now you have money for full coilover kit, a nice set of 17 inch or 18 inch rims, body kit, and any other little stuff you want to do to your car... and you'll still have a lot of money to spare which you can put into savings....
Now you have money for full coilover kit, a nice set of 17 inch or 18 inch rims, body kit, and any other little stuff you want to do to your car... and you'll still have a lot of money to spare which you can put into savings....
Originally posted by SMURF_KILLER
naw my car is payed off and I owe nothing, plus the other 15000 im going to invest.
naw my car is payed off and I owe nothing, plus the other 15000 im going to invest.
but how long will my D17 last if I do all that to my car people say if you turbo or build your motor then the life span of the motor drops I just read this in some other forum is this true
i could be wrong but last time i checked if you do a engine swap, you also should upgrade the suspension as well as several other bolt ons to really tap out all the potential of this new engine. Lets do the math 17,500 for a civic, 3,000 for a K20 engine, around 3,000 for the install including labor and all parts now if you add other bolt ons such as exhaust, intake, new coil over suspension you should be around 27k or more. Now im not saying doing swaps are stupid but for all that cash spent on that install why not just buy a car around that same price for that would still be faster then your car with all those installs???? one that i can think of is the WRX or the EVO 8????


