I was in a slight fender bender a couple weekends ago affecting my passenger front wheel area. I went to pull the wheel off to straighten the fender and one of the nuts stripped. After driving around for a while with three lug nuts I bought a replacement wheel stud to get installed, but need to replace the stripped lug nut. I assume I will need to find the exact lug nut if I want to be able to use the key I have for all the others. Is this possible or should I just look into getting all new lug nuts?
Seems like a typical lug nut with 6 grooves: