Rep Power: 269

I was in a slight fender bender a couple weekends ago affecting my passenger front wheel area. I went to pull the wheel off to straighten the fender and one of the nuts stripped. After driving around for a while with three lug nuts I bought a replacement wheel stud to get installed, but need to replace the stripped lug nut. I assume I will need to find the exact lug nut if I want to be able to use the key I have for all the others. Is this possible or should I just look into getting all new lug nuts?

Seems like a typical lug nut with 6 grooves:

 
Rep Power: 424

Tuner lugs? If you know what brand they are I'd give em a call and see if there's a way to ID the pattern.

 
Rep Power: 269

They were installed when I got new wheels, don't know the manuf. Was too excited at the time to think one day I might need to know how to replace one.

 
Rep Power: 269

After some searching, it appears that it may be these. Still the question, is it possible to get just one or should I just invest in new all around?

 
Rep Power: 812

idk, its hard to say for sure if they are the same. i have a slightly used set of 16 chrome muteki nuts and key i will sell you for $25 shipped if you want. i switched to black.

 
Rep Power: 269

I may take you up on those gearbox if I can't find 1 to match the ones I have. I'd just hate to have 19 extra lug nuts that are basically useless.

 
Rep Power: 0

their spline lugnuts made my gorilla, i have the same ones of my rims, any parts store can order you some, most tire shops have um on hand and some will even sell you one