Rep Power: 0

So I have started experiencing an issue where the car tries to turn over (sounds like maybe twice) and then nothing. I figured maybe it was the battery since its almost 6 years old, so I replaced it with a brand new one, but the issue continues. Some basic diagnostics show that the battery is 12.77v when the car is off and about 14.48v when the car is running. Battery has a full charge based off my car chargers meter.

Any ideas what this could be? My wife purchased the car when it had 96k miles on it and did no maintenance other than the oil changes. My go to was maybe the spark plugs or ignition coils? Would a bad starter cause these issues?

 
Rep Power: 513

try mechanically agitating (read: smacking the crap out of) the starter (solenoid)? Had starting issues with my 2002's starter not wanting to turn the engine over much, if at all. Smacked the s--- out of it with a socket extension and had zero problems after that.

 
Rep Power: 519

When you say "nothing", what else do you see? Dash still lit up? Dash went dark?
Cranked super slow then stopped? Only clicks? Cranked normal speed but engine won't run?

Check amp draw of the starter while this is happening.


Starters fail. Probably needs one.

 
Rep Power: 0

Yea I'm thinking its the starter. Dash is still lit up. It cranks really slow once or twice and then clicking... just tried now and just clicking.