Need opinons
Registered!!
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 104
Likes: 0
From: Melbourne, FL
Rep Power: 0 
go with the G35!!!! theyre hot cars, with great reliability, fvckton of power, and racing inspired spirit, all with a touch of luxury.....and daym it would look hot in all black~~ trust me on this....
Registered!!
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 407
Likes: 0
From: Southeastern Wisconsin
Rep Power: 0 
Go with the 5 series or an M3.
What model Benz do you have now and why are you selling it?
Sell both and you have a nice downpayment on a new AMG (or a slightly used one).
I wouldn't pass up a BMW or a Mercedes-Benz for a G35 which isn't all that great.
What model Benz do you have now and why are you selling it?
Sell both and you have a nice downpayment on a new AMG (or a slightly used one).
I wouldn't pass up a BMW or a Mercedes-Benz for a G35 which isn't all that great.
Last edited by TurboDieselDrew; Mar 2, 2005 at 07:51 PM.
Tighter than a third eye after 1 week in prison.
iTrader: (4)
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 4,608
Likes: 0
From: NorCal.PittsburgWHAT!
Rep Power: 310 g35 
bmw cost a bitch to maintain, i always laugh when my parents take the z3 in and they tell me how much the service was. they should of got an s2000...
bmw cost a bitch to maintain, i always laugh when my parents take the z3 in and they tell me how much the service was. they should of got an s2000...
so one would say that I am partial. G35 is pretty cool too, Maxima is just BLAH 
Registered!!
iTrader: (11)
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 4,576
Likes: 0
From: Lakewood, 562
Rep Power: 320 
maxima = good power, 4 doors thats about it.
g35= good power, sporty styling, and luxury
5 series = more of a luxury styling, good power and awesome warranty.
-BMW has one of the best warranties, but you will have issues with the car.
-Aftermarket items are price of civic aftermarket times 5
BMW makes awesome cars, but they pack so much stuff in there that it breaks. I know because my housemate has a 04 330 ci BMW.
He got his in may of 03 and i got my 04 civic in nov of 03. This is some of his issues and the car has about 15k now. bad starter, got it replaced, bad coils got it replaced, bad window motor, got it replaced. Bad window motor again, same side got it replaced. All those times when his car broke down on the side of the road, BMW payed for towing and gave him a loaner BMW to use till it was fixed and all covered under warranty with no hassles.
Now my 04 civic, as of right now has 32k on it. Car issues......none. ONly took it in to get oil changes.
You can a nice luxury and better social status with the european cars, but you will have issues with them. If you dont mind going to the dealer a lot then go with the 5 series. My friend wishes he just bought a g35 now because as much as he loves his bimmer, his 98 nissan 200sx with 140k on is more reliable at the moment then his 04 bimmer with 15k on it.
g35= good power, sporty styling, and luxury
5 series = more of a luxury styling, good power and awesome warranty.
-BMW has one of the best warranties, but you will have issues with the car.
-Aftermarket items are price of civic aftermarket times 5
BMW makes awesome cars, but they pack so much stuff in there that it breaks. I know because my housemate has a 04 330 ci BMW.
He got his in may of 03 and i got my 04 civic in nov of 03. This is some of his issues and the car has about 15k now. bad starter, got it replaced, bad coils got it replaced, bad window motor, got it replaced. Bad window motor again, same side got it replaced. All those times when his car broke down on the side of the road, BMW payed for towing and gave him a loaner BMW to use till it was fixed and all covered under warranty with no hassles.
Now my 04 civic, as of right now has 32k on it. Car issues......none. ONly took it in to get oil changes.
You can a nice luxury and better social status with the european cars, but you will have issues with them. If you dont mind going to the dealer a lot then go with the 5 series. My friend wishes he just bought a g35 now because as much as he loves his bimmer, his 98 nissan 200sx with 140k on is more reliable at the moment then his 04 bimmer with 15k on it.
Titanium Metallic. You got a problem with that?
iTrader: (8)
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 6,496
Likes: 0
From: So Cal
Rep Power: 351 I was in LOVE with the G35, literally a signiture away from driving home in one, than I see a catalog on the 2005. Looks and sounds so much better. So I wait. Go and see the 2005 in person, and Im kicking myself for waiting. Yeah, +18 hp, but NO BREMBOS, -10 ft/lb tq, 100 lbs heavier. Yeah the 19z are nice, esp the forged ones, but iono. Now im just gonna keep my car until 2007 when the GT-R comes out.
Out of that list, I say go for the Maxima. Its more suitable as a daily beater, a shietload more room, and looks are pretty good, and Im not a fan of the car. I must say tho, Nissan did a pretty good job with the looks. So go with that. Insurance will also be much nicer on the maxima than the Sport Coupe G.
EDIT - Oh yeah, the Bimmer. Um . . . . . . . unless your gonna lease it, I wouldnt do it. Im usually against leases, but once you are out of your warranty with BMW, and out of thier free service plan, its soo expensive to repair, and everything falls apart right as soon as the warranty is over. Have a 98 528i, and many problems after free service and warranty. It has 105,000 miles, currently replacing the CV joint. Not the same BMW quality it used to have.
Out of that list, I say go for the Maxima. Its more suitable as a daily beater, a shietload more room, and looks are pretty good, and Im not a fan of the car. I must say tho, Nissan did a pretty good job with the looks. So go with that. Insurance will also be much nicer on the maxima than the Sport Coupe G.
EDIT - Oh yeah, the Bimmer. Um . . . . . . . unless your gonna lease it, I wouldnt do it. Im usually against leases, but once you are out of your warranty with BMW, and out of thier free service plan, its soo expensive to repair, and everything falls apart right as soon as the warranty is over. Have a 98 528i, and many problems after free service and warranty. It has 105,000 miles, currently replacing the CV joint. Not the same BMW quality it used to have.
Last edited by Nodnero; Mar 2, 2005 at 10:16 PM.
Hey! Look At Me!! I'm a Supporting Member!!
iTrader: (3)
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 1,760
Likes: 0
From: Jersey Shore
Rep Power: 292
Originally Posted by gearbox
yea vtechgrl you would look good in the g35. I'd turn and stare! 
Registered!!
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 427
Likes: 0
From: West Palm Beach, Florida
Rep Power: 0 It's interesting hearing these quality issues with BMWs. I come from a BMW family and we have never experienced anything like that. I've had to replace my brake discs several times, but I race in the car, so that is nothing shocking.
Registered!!
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 427
Likes: 0
From: West Palm Beach, Florida
Rep Power: 0 These stories of BMW problems are new to me. I come from a BMW family and we've never had any problems. I have had to replace my disc brakes a few times on the M3, but then agian, I race, so nothing that is unexpected...
.................................................. ..................
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,493
Likes: 0
Rep Power: 275 ^^^I worked as a mechanic specializing in BMW and Mercedes....and after working on them, seeing what goes wrong, and having to go buy parts....
.....makes me NEVER want to own either BMW or Mercedes
.....makes me NEVER want to own either BMW or Mercedes
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally Posted by TurboDieselDrew
Go with the 5 series or an M3.
What model Benz do you have now and why are you selling it?
Sell both and you have a nice downpayment on a new AMG (or a slightly used one).
I wouldn't pass up a BMW or a Mercedes-Benz for a G35 which isn't all that great.
What model Benz do you have now and why are you selling it?
Sell both and you have a nice downpayment on a new AMG (or a slightly used one).
I wouldn't pass up a BMW or a Mercedes-Benz for a G35 which isn't all that great.
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally Posted by Nodnero
I was in LOVE with the G35, literally a signiture away from driving home in one, than I see a catalog on the 2005. Looks and sounds so much better. So I wait. Go and see the 2005 in person, and Im kicking myself for waiting. Yeah, +18 hp, but NO BREMBOS, -10 ft/lb tq, 100 lbs heavier. Yeah the 19z are nice, esp the forged ones, but iono. Now im just gonna keep my car until 2007 when the GT-R comes out.
Out of that list, I say go for the Maxima. Its more suitable as a daily beater, a shietload more room, and looks are pretty good, and Im not a fan of the car. I must say tho, Nissan did a pretty good job with the looks. So go with that. Insurance will also be much nicer on the maxima than the Sport Coupe G.
EDIT - Oh yeah, the Bimmer. Um . . . . . . . unless your gonna lease it, I wouldnt do it. Im usually against leases, but once you are out of your warranty with BMW, and out of thier free service plan, its soo expensive to repair, and everything falls apart right as soon as the warranty is over. Have a 98 528i, and many problems after free service and warranty. It has 105,000 miles, currently replacing the CV joint. Not the same BMW quality it used to have.
Out of that list, I say go for the Maxima. Its more suitable as a daily beater, a shietload more room, and looks are pretty good, and Im not a fan of the car. I must say tho, Nissan did a pretty good job with the looks. So go with that. Insurance will also be much nicer on the maxima than the Sport Coupe G.
EDIT - Oh yeah, the Bimmer. Um . . . . . . . unless your gonna lease it, I wouldnt do it. Im usually against leases, but once you are out of your warranty with BMW, and out of thier free service plan, its soo expensive to repair, and everything falls apart right as soon as the warranty is over. Have a 98 528i, and many problems after free service and warranty. It has 105,000 miles, currently replacing the CV joint. Not the same BMW quality it used to have.
something about the maxima i just like,.... so well see i guess, im going to test drive the g35 and the maxima on saturday
