Should I fix my cracked tail light
 

My left side tail light in the quarter panel is cracked. I have found a new one on rockauto for forty dollars. Then I would be done. Everything back to stock.
I was looking on ebay and had seen some nice looking aftermarket lights. Maybe around 75 dollars for a pair. I don't want anything tinted or smoked, but something more "legal". I saw the write ups on modifying the tail lights and think they look real nice. It is just that I do not want any hassles with a ticket or what not.
So my question is what do you guys think are the nicest looking after market tail lights, led? Stay stock? My car is 2001 4 dr civic hatchback.